We loved our first experience at Hotel Cashiers when we first came about 2 years ago so of course we wanted to come back.
Pros: The staff are so friendly and helpful. The location is great, walking distance to most things in central Cashiers. Also, their restaurant is so so good!
Cons: Our towels had hair in them from previous guests, the bathtub didn't drain properly, there was food leftover from the previous guest in our refrigerator, and some of the surfaces in the room hadn't been wiped down. There was also dog poop in some of the common outdoor areas. At times, our room keypad wouldn't work requiring several attempts and waiting before being able to try again.
I know that there has likely been a high turnover in rooms with aid coming into help with disaster relief for the surrounding areas, so trying to be understanding. However, the lack of room cleanliness was a big issue.